Audit Supervisor - NFP

A growing CPA firm in Bergen County, NJ, is seeking an Audit Supervisor with at least 7 years of public accounting experience specializing in nonprofit organizations. They're looking for a seasoned auditor who can step into complex client situations, take full ownership, and elevate both the team and the practice. This is a true leadership-minded role with meaningful impact.

About the role: Lead audit engagements, manage and mentor staff, review work, prepare deliverables, and guide clients through strategic planning. You'll be hands-on with a diverse mix of nonprofit organizations that demand real technical depth, including:

• Risk assessment
• Preparation of financial statements and disclosures
• Uniform Guidance audits
• Preparation of Form 990 returns for tax-exempt organizations

This role does not involve:

• Public company or SEC work
• Big-firm siloed specialization If that's your background or primary interest, this may not be the right fit.

Key Responsibilities

• Supervise staff during fieldwork, review workpapers, and provide constructive guidance and suggestions
• Develop testing methodologies to evaluate the adequacy of internal controls
• Review audit findings, recommend changes in accounting practices, and improve client efficiencies through corrective action plans
• Recommend corrective actions and offer operational improvements
• Supervise, mentor, and develop staff and seniors; manage workloads and deadlines effectively
• Build and maintain strong client relationships through ongoing communication and best-in-class service
• Stay current with changes in laws, accounting guidance, and related compliance matters
• Contribute to internal process improvements and best-practice refinement

Required Qualifications

• Active CPA license preferred
• Minimum 7 years of progressive public accounting experience
• Deep knowledge of nonprofit accounting
• Strong background in Uniform Guidance audits
• Strong background in preparing Form 990 returns for exempt organizations
• Demonstrated leadership with a track record of developing staff and managing client engagements
• Ability to handle multiple priorities without losing accuracy or momentum
• Solid working knowledge of ProSystem Engagement, PPC Smart Tools, ProSystem fx, QuickBooks, and QuickBooks Online is a plus

What They Offer

• A stable client base of nonprofit organizations
• A firm culture that values accountability, professionalism, and exceptional client service
• Competitive compensation, benefits, and opportunities for long-term growth
• A clear partner-track path for the right candidate